"Everything is premium. We have wraps and bowls." That is how Anthony Assaly, manager of House of Garlic, described the menu to The Times of Northwest Indiana when the family's food truck opened its first restaurant in Ross Plaza on U.S. 30. It is the newest version of a pattern that runs through Merrillville's independent dining. The family-owned restaurants with real history here mostly started as something smaller somewhere else in the Region, and they ended up a turn or two off the chain corridor, on 81st Avenue, East 84th Drive and Broadway.
So the restaurants come with family histories you can trace, and that matters in the weeks between Thanksgiving and New Year's, when out-of-town relatives ask where to eat and a chain on U.S. 30 doesn't feel like much of an answer.
81st Avenue holds the oldest lineage and the newest arrival
At 1800 81st Ave., the building that was Johnny's Round the Clock became Brothers Pancake House in 2019. According to The Times, it went from a 24-hour diner to breakfast and lunch and got Edison bulbs and a more contemporary room. Owners Anna and Manny Saitis named it for the five brothers who came from Greece and started the Round the Clock chain in Gary in 1968. That makes the name a direct line back to one of the Region's best-known diner families.
The menu Brothers reported shows where it came from. Breakfast includes a Gyro Hero omelet and the Steel Worker, made with bacon, sausage, ham, mushroom, peppers, onion and cheddar. Lunch moves to Greek pork chops, Grecian chicken and lemon rice soup. The same Times report said Brothers was expanding to a second location at 81 Silhavy Road in Valparaiso, in the former TGI Fridays building. You can call ahead at 219-769-1591.
Farther down the same road, House of Garlic sits at 431 81st Ave. in Ross Plaza. The quick-serve menu is chicken, shawarma, kebabs and falafel, and the restaurant calls itself a celebration of "garlic, culture and community." It started as a food truck based in Hebron that worked events across Northwest Indiana. Before the opening, The Times reported that Executive Chef Elie Assaly, who came from corporate hospitality, specializes in Lebanese food. That preview listed Lebanese steak shawarma, garlic steak fries, garlic cilantro fries and a garlic spread. The truck still runs and still does catering and special events.
Brothers comes from a family business founded in 1968, and House of Garlic moved off a truck into a storefront. Between them, 81st Avenue has about the full range of how a family restaurant gets started in this part of Indiana.
East 84th Drive is where the Gamba family landed
Gamba Ristorante, at 455 E. 84th Drive, has its own long run-up. In a Times profile, Michaelle Gamba said her father, Benito, left Altomonte, a hillside town in southern Italy, and worked at Chicago restaurants including The Cottage and Cricket's, where he met his wife, Hilda. He opened Café Venezia in 1988, then Venezia Bar and Grill, and later combined the two into one restaurant in Merrillville. Gamba Ristorante opened in March 2006.
The family still runs the dining room. Benito and Hilda own it, daughters Michaelle and Krystle are managers, and the same profile said Michaelle's daughter, Cynthia, had started tending bar. Michaelle said the ravioli and sauces are made from scratch and the recipes come from Benito's family. "We're family-owned, and the regulars who come here become family," she said.
Gamba also cooks more than one kind of Italian. For a regional dinner series in the courtyard, The Times wrote, chef Mike Rueth put together a Le Marche menu with fritto misto of calamari, smelt and shrimp, a lasagna-style vincigrassi and whole grilled branzino. Benito described the restaurant as Northern Italian with dishes drawn from other regions. Reservations are at 219-736-5000.
Gamba was also on the South Shore Convention and Visitors Authority's 2026 Thanksgiving dining guide, published Nov. 11, with a heat-and-eat turkey menu, more than 20 years after the restaurant opened.
Broadway puts dinner next door to Town Hall
Asparagus is at 7876 Broadway. Like Gamba, it grew out of an earlier restaurant. According to the restaurant's own history, owner-chef Tammy Pham bought a small Thai storefront in a Calumet City strip mall in 1995 and turned a linoleum-counter takeout spot into a dining room people kept coming back to. She and her husband, Sam Chung, later opened Siam Marina II in River Oaks Mall. Asparagus was named the South Shore CVA's 2008 Restaurant of the Year 14 months after it opened, and the restaurant says it has kept winning regional awards since.
The Times has called the spicy baked salmon a specialty. The building is a good fit for holiday groups. It seats more than 250, the Lemon Grass Room holds private parties of up to 70, and the Waterfall Room seats 16 next to a lounge with a baby grand piano. Ordering is online through the restaurant's site.
The address matters this weekend. The Town of Merrillville's annual Holiday Tree Lighting Ceremony runs from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 21, at the Merrillville Municipal Complex, 7820 Broadway. Santa will be there, and the Merrillville High School Choir will sing, according to the town's website. On Broadway, 7876 is just up the street from 7820. For a family that wants dinner after the lights come on without getting back in the car for U.S. 30, Asparagus is the closest sit-down room.
At the other end of Broadway, Wings Galore American Kitchen opened at 5460 Broadway. The Times reported that it serves Buffalo, boneless and whole wings, tilapia, catfish, panko-breaded shrimp, pizza puffs and Philly cheesesteaks, along with chicken, shrimp and veggie fried rice. It is a small local chain with locations in Calumet City, Oak Park and Park Forest. Like House of Garlic, it came to Merrillville already up and running somewhere else.
Mississippi Street and the mall's old Tilted Kilt building
Southlake Mall, which The Times calls Indiana's second-largest enclosed mall, is where most people picture Merrillville's chains. Its newest restaurant took a building that had sat empty. The Times reported that Yummy Bowl, a Mongolian stir-fry and sushi restaurant, moved into the long-vacant Tilted Kilt building on Mississippi Street. "We are excited to announce that Yummy Bowl is officially open," Southlake Mall marketing and business development manager Kristyn Filetti told the paper. If you are at the mall for holiday shopping, it is a stir-fry stop that doesn't involve the food court.
Thanksgiving week, by address
Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26. Merrillville has two ways to skip cooking that week, plus one change worth knowing about.
Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant is the exception to the off-the-strip pattern, but it is the main Merrillville Thanksgiving Day option in the South Shore CVA's 2026 guide. The full Thanksgiving menu runs all day alongside the regular menu. As of the guide's Nov. 11 publication, dinner was $36.99 for adults and $15.99 for kids 12 and under. The take-home kit serves six for $199.99. It includes sliced slow-roasted turkey, stuffing, Mary's Potatoes, butternut squash soup and a pumpkin praline cheesecake. Orders close Friday, Nov. 20, which is tomorrow for anyone reading this on publish day, and pickup is Wednesday, Nov. 25, or Thursday, Nov. 26, between 9 a.m. and 1 p.m.
The change is at Merrillville Florist and Tea Room on Madison Street. Its website says the Tea Room is no longer a full-service restaurant for everyday dining and now hosts private events and gatherings only. The holiday weekend is the exception. The CVA guide lists a Thanksgiving Weekend Feast at the Tea Room on Saturday, Nov. 28, and Sunday, Nov. 29, with a charcuterie table, salad bar, turkey, ham, a mashed potato bar and homemade desserts. Reservations go through an online ticket link. If the Tea Room used to be your lunch spot, that weekend is a chance to sit in that room again with a reservation.
The CVA guide also advises confirming holiday hours, menus and prices directly with each restaurant before you go.
For more on the town's warm-weather calendar along the same corridor, see our post on how a Merrillville summer runs on Broadway, and our Merrillville neighborhood page has more about the town.
Knowing which side street holds which family kitchen is part of knowing Merrillville, and it is the kind of local detail the team at Larita Thomas Group brings to every conversation. If you live near Broadway, 81st Avenue or 84th Drive and wonder what your home is worth this season, get your free instant home valuation or schedule a consultation with us.